Users like you have given feedback on this thread:
To give your opinion, vote using the thumbs above.
To give your opinion, vote using the thumbs above.
97% | ||
3% |
Share this thread on the web:
Share this thread by Email:
Click here
del.icio.us
StumbleUpon
Google Bookmarks
Technorati
reddit |
Windows Live
Yahoo! My Web
Facebook
AOL IM
|
Share this thread by Email:
Click here
DEAD: Trendnet TEW-652BRP Linux 802.11n draft 2.0 wireless router, Newegg $25 FS, no rebate
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Pro...6833156242
Very hot deal. $25 with free shipping has come up on Buy.com and Fry's with these, now Newegg. A modern Linux-based 802.11n router! They sell out frequently.
Pros:
-- Router can be flashed with D-Link DIR-615 revision C1 firmware; the two routers are compatible (but this does void your warranty).
-- Linux 2.6 based router, can now run OpenWRT (but still early in the OpenWRT game)
-- 2x2 MIMO antenna router, 802.11n. Atheros ar9102 radio chip. 2.4Ghz band.
-- 32MB of RAM, 4MB of FLASH, and 400Mhz MIPS CPU. Favourable to older Linux routers like the Linksys WRT54GL.
-- two removable antennas with standard connectors, RP-SMA connector
-- very small size, tiny router.
-- For those inclined: router is easy to open, 4 screws, no snaps. rs232 serial port is easy to solder on this router if you want to experiment with the Linux. You can buy a USB to serial adapter for Nokia cell phone DKU-5 on eBay for $3.70 (free shipping, one eBay seller [ebay.com]), solder 3 wires, and get Linux root on the router. DKU-5 instructions page [nas-central.org]
Cons:
-- The wireless drivers are new and not perfectly mature. 802.11n is a new game and it takes time for them to get software drivers just right. Some of the reviews reflect that. It works today, but firmware updates and such will improve in future.
-- no dd-wrt yet, speculate within 3 months
-- 2x2 MIMO antenna design, 3x3 MIMO 2.4Ghz is better but not to be found for $25! Cheapest I've found is $45.
-- Does not do 5Ghz or mixed 2.4+5Ghz. Again, what do you expect for $25?!
-- antennas are short, the Planex and TP-Link versions of this router I have come with ones 50% longer.
-- 100Mbps switch speed. What do you expect for $25? And WiFi has a lot of overhead (latency), so even if you connect WiFi at 230Mbps you really get equal to a 100Mbps cabled network speeds. Yes, gigabit ethernet ports would be nice.
-- Tendnet firmware is pretty crappy. Missing features, etc. Hopefully they keep improving it.
-- You can't run Tomato or other Linux router firmware that is stuck in the stone ages of 802.11g Broadcom routers. Maybe in the future, OpenWRT and dd-wrt tends to be the first and the others follow.
Links:
-- OpenWRT: http://forum.openwrt.org/viewtopic.php?id=18314
-- Trendnet firmware download page: http://www.trendnet.com/downloads...PE_ID=1259
-- dd-wrt thread on how to flash with D-Link firmware, etc. NOTE: Does not support dd-wrt at this time, only OpenWRT. That may change in the future. http://www.dd-wrt.com/phpBB2/view...p?p=254664
UP FRONT: This is a modern 802.11n draft 2 router, but in general the software on these new routers is not real mature. This router isn't perfect, the Tendnet firmware isn't so great (the D-Link has more features). Reviews of routers tend to be a lot about the software and driver problems, and this one is no different. That's why being Linux-based is of interest - you have options if the Trendnet or D-Link don't bother to update the router down the road.
I really want to draw attention to people who are into Linux to this router platform (Atheros AP81). I have scoured the Internet for 2 months and put together a list of all the ones based on this Atheros chipset. See here: http://wiki.openwrt.org/AtherosAR9100 OpenWRT can be flashed on this Trendnet router and we have now working the ath9k totally open drivers! However, the ath9k drivers aren't yet optimised for these slow router CPU's (ath9k is only 6 months old and mostly focused on desktop systems). Two months down the road I think we have a really nice OpenWRT router. Do you want to help get involved in the testing of OpenWRT - please do - but please have proper expectations of both the factory Trendnet firmware and the status of OpenWRT. This is all about a future where WiFi isn't so unstable and unpredictable.
Very hot deal. $25 with free shipping has come up on Buy.com and Fry's with these, now Newegg. A modern Linux-based 802.11n router! They sell out frequently.
Pros:
-- Router can be flashed with D-Link DIR-615 revision C1 firmware; the two routers are compatible (but this does void your warranty).
-- Linux 2.6 based router, can now run OpenWRT (but still early in the OpenWRT game)
-- 2x2 MIMO antenna router, 802.11n. Atheros ar9102 radio chip. 2.4Ghz band.
-- 32MB of RAM, 4MB of FLASH, and 400Mhz MIPS CPU. Favourable to older Linux routers like the Linksys WRT54GL.
-- two removable antennas with standard connectors, RP-SMA connector
-- very small size, tiny router.
-- For those inclined: router is easy to open, 4 screws, no snaps. rs232 serial port is easy to solder on this router if you want to experiment with the Linux. You can buy a USB to serial adapter for Nokia cell phone DKU-5 on eBay for $3.70 (free shipping, one eBay seller [ebay.com]), solder 3 wires, and get Linux root on the router. DKU-5 instructions page [nas-central.org]
Cons:
-- The wireless drivers are new and not perfectly mature. 802.11n is a new game and it takes time for them to get software drivers just right. Some of the reviews reflect that. It works today, but firmware updates and such will improve in future.
-- no dd-wrt yet, speculate within 3 months
-- 2x2 MIMO antenna design, 3x3 MIMO 2.4Ghz is better but not to be found for $25! Cheapest I've found is $45.
-- Does not do 5Ghz or mixed 2.4+5Ghz. Again, what do you expect for $25?!
-- antennas are short, the Planex and TP-Link versions of this router I have come with ones 50% longer.
-- 100Mbps switch speed. What do you expect for $25? And WiFi has a lot of overhead (latency), so even if you connect WiFi at 230Mbps you really get equal to a 100Mbps cabled network speeds. Yes, gigabit ethernet ports would be nice.
-- Tendnet firmware is pretty crappy. Missing features, etc. Hopefully they keep improving it.
-- You can't run Tomato or other Linux router firmware that is stuck in the stone ages of 802.11g Broadcom routers. Maybe in the future, OpenWRT and dd-wrt tends to be the first and the others follow.
Links:
-- OpenWRT: http://forum.openwrt.org/viewtopic.php?id=18314
-- Trendnet firmware download page: http://www.trendnet.com/downloads...PE_ID=1259
-- dd-wrt thread on how to flash with D-Link firmware, etc. NOTE: Does not support dd-wrt at this time, only OpenWRT. That may change in the future. http://www.dd-wrt.com/phpBB2/view...p?p=254664
UP FRONT: This is a modern 802.11n draft 2 router, but in general the software on these new routers is not real mature. This router isn't perfect, the Tendnet firmware isn't so great (the D-Link has more features). Reviews of routers tend to be a lot about the software and driver problems, and this one is no different. That's why being Linux-based is of interest - you have options if the Trendnet or D-Link don't bother to update the router down the road.
I really want to draw attention to people who are into Linux to this router platform (Atheros AP81). I have scoured the Internet for 2 months and put together a list of all the ones based on this Atheros chipset. See here: http://wiki.openwrt.org/AtherosAR9100 OpenWRT can be flashed on this Trendnet router and we have now working the ath9k totally open drivers! However, the ath9k drivers aren't yet optimised for these slow router CPU's (ath9k is only 6 months old and mostly focused on desktop systems). Two months down the road I think we have a really nice OpenWRT router. Do you want to help get involved in the testing of OpenWRT - please do - but please have proper expectations of both the factory Trendnet firmware and the status of OpenWRT. This is all about a future where WiFi isn't so unstable and unpredictable.
Last edited by RoundSparrow; 01-28-2009 at 07:15 AM..
Reason: Price raised to $40







WiFi is just this way, maybe you have been lucky in the past. Maybe people help figure out better settings, new firmware come, etc. In worst case put the damn router on the shelf for 3 weeks and try again later.








